4 > 10? JPEG quality settings

Discussion of Photoshop Scripting, Photoshop Actions and Photoshop Automation in General

Moderators: Tom, Kukurykus

kpt

4 > 10? JPEG quality settings

Post by kpt »

Every once in a while, someone claims that a level-12 JPEG can be saved, opened, saved, etc, many times without loss of quality.

I decided to write a script to test this, not only for level 12 but also level 10 and level 4.

Here is the script:
Code: Select allvar FILE04 = "/tmp/clock-level-04.jpg";
var FILE10 = "/tmp/clock-level-10.jpg";
var FILE12 = "/tmp/clock-level-12.jpg";

var jpeg12Options = new JPEGSaveOptions();
var jpeg10Options = new JPEGSaveOptions();
var jpeg04Options = new JPEGSaveOptions();

jpeg12Options.quality = 12;
jpeg10Options.quality = 10;
jpeg04Options.quality =  4;

function OpenSaveJPEG(f, jpo) {
  var fref1 = new File(f);
  var fref2 = new File(f);
  open(fref1);
  var docRef = app.activeDocument;
  docRef.saveAs(fref2, jpo);
  docRef.close();
  fref1 = null;
  fref2 = null;
}

var startDisplayDialogs = app.displayDialogs;
app.displayDialogs = DialogModes.NO;

for (i = 0; i < 20; i++) OpenSaveJPEG(FILE04, jpeg04Options);
for (i = 0; i < 20; i++) OpenSaveJPEG(FILE10, jpeg10Options);
for (i = 0; i < 20; i++) OpenSaveJPEG(FILE12, jpeg12Options);

app.displayDialogs = startDisplayDialogs;


Here is the original image:



Here is the result of twenty open & save at quality 4:



Here is the result of twenty open & save at quality 10:



Here is the result of twenty open & save at quality 12:




Now, why does quality 10 look worse than quality 4?

Or is there a bug in my script?

(This test was done in CS3 on a Mac.)